1908 – Winners – CALGARY CALEDONIANS
July 2, 1908, at St. Mary's Grounds in Calgary
Calgary Caledonians  1
Edmonton Caledonians  0
(No scorers or lineups in either the Calgary Herald or the Edmonton Journal)

1909 – Winners – CALGARY CALEDONIANS
September 11, 1909, at Diamond Park in Edmonton
Edmonton Caledonians  0
Calgary Caledonians  2 (Sellars, Towell)
HT: 0–0    Att:           Ref:
Edmonton: P. Tod – Tweedale, McKenzie – Adams, Dow, Cowan – Gibson,
  Stedman, A. Tod, Charlie Smail, Lloyd.
Calgary: W. Strang – A. Veitch, Donald McKechnie – James Haig,
   Alex Strang, James Petrie – A. Sellars, Geordie Johnstone,
   William Stewart, Tom Stewart, Joe Towell.

1910 – Winners – CALGARY CALEDONIANS
September 15, 1910, in Calgary
Calgary Caledonians  2
Lloydminster  0 

1911 – Winners – CALGARY CALEDONIANS
September 30, 1911, at Mewata Park in Calgary
Calgary Caledonians  4 (Spalding, W. Stewart 2, Williams)
Edmonton Swifts  0
HT: 2–0    Att:           Ref: R. Gee (Red Deer)
Calgary: Jimmy Gilhooley – Grindley, Charlie Cooper – James Haig,
   Alex Strang, James Petrie – Tom Stewart, William Stewart, Williams,
   McLean, Spalding.
Edmonton: Lou Phillips – Jack Towns, James Moffat – A. McCormack,
   A. Crews, James Alexander – William Thompson, J. Patterson, A. Barton,
   J.H.A. Lloyd, A.E. Manton.

1912 – Winners – CALGARY CALEDONIANS
October 19, 1912, at Hillhurst Park in Calgary
Calgary Caledonians  1 (Wilson)
Edmonton Caledonians  0
HT: 0–0    Att:           Ref: J. Gurr (Lethbridge)
Edmonton: Parker – Kinsman, McIntosh – McPherson, Whitehead,
  Hunter – Collier, Saunders, Tweedale, Chapman, Bilsland.
Calgary: Jimmy Gilhooley – Grindley, Mitch McLean – Braidwood, Strang,
  James Petrie – Powell, Nesbitt, Wilson, Williams, Mathewson.

1913 – Winners – EDMONTON CALEDONIANS
October 4, 1913, at Diamond Park in Edmonton
Edmonton Caledonians  2 (Tweedale 2)
Calgary Caledonians  0
HT: 1–0    Att:           Ref:
Edmonton: Parker – Kinsman, McIntosh – McPherson, Whitehead,
  Cowan – Collier, McLuckie, Tweedale, Dickie, Davidson.
Calgary: Jimmy Gilhooley – Stewart, Charlie Cooper – James Haig,
  Mitch McLean, James Petrie – Joe Towell, Feeney, Williams, Nisbet,
  Bennett.

1914 – Competition not completed

1915 – Winners – LLOYDMINSTER