1936 – Winners – MONTREAL CARSTEEL
October 10, 1936, in Toronto – Final First Leg
Toronto Ulster  3 (McQueston 2, Aiken)
Montreal Carsteel  5  (Hutchinson, Shorrock 2, Bennett, ?)
HT: 3–4   Att:          Ref:  W. Newton
Ulster: Wilson – Bill Davison, Doug McBride – Harold McCullough, Norman
  Bundy, Bob McNabney – Harry McQueston, Johnny Aiken, George
  Graham, Sam McNabney, Jimmy Moir.  (Sub: Bob Hume)
Carsteel:  McLean – Max “Red” Epstein, George White – Tim Gordon,
  Laing, Herb Leah – Sam Chedgzoy, George  Chambers, Dick Shorrock.
  Billy Bennett, Hutchinson.  (Subs: Pollock. Atkinson, McDonald)

October 12, 1936, in Toronto
Toronto Ulster  0
Montreal Carsteel  1  (Hutchinson)
HT: 0–1   Att: 1000    Ref:
Ulster: Wilson – Bill Davison, Doug McBride – Harold McCullough, Norman
  Bundy, James Loney – McQueston, Johnny Aiken, George Graham, Sam
  McNabney, Jimmy Moir.  (Subs: Bill Quinn, R. McNabney)   
Carsteel: McLean – Max “Red” Epstein, George White – Tim Gordon, Laing,
  Herb Leah – Sam Chedgzoy, George Chambers, Dick Shorrock, Billy
  Bennett, Hutchinson.  (Subs: Pollock, Bill Allison)

1937 – Winners – TORONTO BRITISH CONSOLS
October 23, 1937, in Toronto
British Consols  1  (Paterson)
Falconbridge Falcons  3  (Aird 2, Samson)
HT: 1–2   Att:          Ref: D. Rae (Hamilton)
Consols: Dick Arends – Paterson, Weir – McLean, Joe Clulow, Adams –
  Ollie Sutton, Cairns, Paterson, McKissock, Gibson (Garrett)
Falcons: Wallace – Charlie Moore, Jim Lone – Phillips, Cyril Davis,
  Hutchison – McAllister, Aird, Rowarth, Henry Lone, Sheppard (Sampson,
  McArthur, subs?)

October 25, 1937, in Toronto
British Consols  5  (Paterson 3, Sutton, Cairns)
Falconbridge Falcons  1  (Moore)
HT: 1–0   Att:          Ref: D. Rae (Hamilton)
Consols: Dick Arends – Paterson, Weir – McLean, Joe Clulow, Adams –
  Ollie Sutton, Cairns, Paterson, McKissock, Gibson. (Garrett)
Falcons: Bob McArthur – Charlie Moore, Jim Lone – Phillips, Cyril Davis,
  Hutchison – McAllister, Aird, Rowarth, Henry Lone, Sheppard, (Sampson,
  sub?)

Wallace was injured in the first game and couldn't play in the second.  Bob
  McArthur, a forward, took his place.

1938 – Winners – ROYAL VICTORIA HOSPITAL
Western final – September 24, 1938
Toronto Ulster  3
Toronto Maple Leafs  1

September 26, 1938
Toronto Ulster  6
Toronto Maple Leafs  2

Final postponed until the spring of 1939, but was never played.  Championship awarded to Montreal Royal Victoria Hospital.

1939 – Winners –
Western final – September 21, 1939
Toronto British Consols  2 
Toronto Ulster  2

September 23, 1939
Toronto British Consols  1
Toronto Ulster  0

NSL final – Toronto British Consols vs Montreal Carsteel

1940 – Winners – MONTREAL CARSTEEL
October 5, 1940, at the Maisonneuve Grounds in Montreal
Montreal Carsteel  3
Toronto Maple Leafs  2
HT:      Att:         Ref:
Carsteel: Tim Gordon – Robert Dunlop, George White – Grundie, Max “Red”
  Epstein, Archie Gammon – Roland Castonguay, Sutherland, Doug
  McMahon, Bill Craig, George Chambers (Marcel Castonguay, Herb Leah,
  Saunders, subs?)
Leafs: Oliver – Jordan, McLean – Adam Inch, D. White, Cairns – McGarva,
  Clark, Nuskisson, Ross, Bugden (Farrimand, West, Cook, subs?)

October 6, 1940, at the Glen Yards Grounds in Montreal
Montreal Carsteel  2
Toronto Maple Leafs  1
Carsteel:
Leafs:

No lineups in either the Montreal Star or Gazette, or the Toronto Telegram

1941 – Winners – TORONTO ULSTER UNITED
October 11, 1941, in Toronto
Toronto Ulster  0
Montreal Carsteel  1  (McMahon)
HT: 0–0   Att:          Ref: R. Auld
Ulster: Breedon – Bill Davison, Doug McBride – Chalmers, Adams,
  McDowall – Porter, Johnny Aiken, Tommy Axe, Bob Hume, George
  Graham.  (Subs: Harold McCullough, Jimmy Moir) 
Carsteel: Tim Gordon – George White, Lone – Sutherland, Samson, Archie
  Gammon – Castonguay, McDougall, Doug McMahon, George Chambers,
  Hutchinson.

October 13, 1941, in Toronto
Toronto Ulster  2
Montreal Carsteel  0
Ulster:
Carsteel: