1916 – Winners – Joint Winners – Hamilton Westinghouse and Toronto
  Eatons
Sept 30, 1916, at Varsity Stadium in Toronto
Toronto Eatons  4
Hamilton Westinghouse  1
HT:           Att:           Ref:
Eatons: McLeary – Campbell, Buchan – Adams, Baldwin, Brookes –
  Anderson, Lindsay, Robertson, Martin, Harrison.
Westinghouse: Crompton – McCulloch, H. Thombs – Ure, Wands, Addison
  – Atkinson, Howard, Howison, Wilson, Aitken.

October 14, 1916, in Hamilton – First Replay
Hamilton Westinghouse  4
Toronto Eatons  1
HT:           Att:           Ref: W.S. Murchie (Toronto)
Westinghouse: Crompton – Rodgers, Barron – Ure, Wands, Willis –
  Ellison, Howison, Tiny Thombs, Wilson, Howard.
Eatons: McLeary – Campbell, Buchan – Adams, Baldwin, Brookes –
  Anderson, Lindsay, Robertson, Harrison, Hamilton.

October 21, 1916 – Second Replay
Toronto Eatons  1
Hamilton Westinghouse  0
HT:           Att:           Ref:  Millsip
Eatons: Adgey – Campbell, Buchan – Adams, Martin, Brookes – Anderson,
  Hamilton, Robertson, Lindsay, Harrison.
Westinghouse: Crompton – Rodgers, Barron – Ure, Wands, Addison –
  Willis, Ellison, Wilson, Howison, Tiny Thombs.

November 11, 1916, at Varsity Stadium in Toronto – Third Replay
Toronto Eatons  1
Hamilton Westinghouse  2
HT:           Att:           Ref:
Eatons: Adgey – Campbell, Buchan – Adams, Martin, Brookes – Anderson,
  Hamilton, Robertson, Lindsay, Harrison.
Westinghouse: Crompton – H. Rodgers, McCulloch – Addison, Wands,
  Stewart – Howison, W. Rodgers, Barnes, Atkinson, Tiny Thombs.

November – Fourth Replay

Joint Champions, teams all square after five games.

1917 – No Final Played

1918 – Winners – TORONTO SCOTTISH
September 28, 1918
Toronto Scottish  1 (Fidler)
Davenport Albion  0
HT: 0–0       Att:           Ref:
Scottish: Steve Smith – Geordie Campbell, William Brownlie – Harry
  A’Court, Young, James – Harry Anderson, H. Fidler, Houison, Ernie Fidler,
  Hunter.
Albion: Enfield – Robinson, Buchan – Brown, Adams, Brookes – Barron, A.
  Walker, McNeilly, S. Walker, Simpson.

1919 – Winners – TORONTO OLD COUNTRY
August 2, 1919, at Varsity Stadium in Toronto
Toronto Old Country  4 (Aitken, Hutchinson, Bell, McKee)
Hamilton Independent Labour Party 2 (Housin, Scholes)
HT: 1–2       Att: 6000     Ref: O. Hill (St, Catharines)
Old Country: Wilcock – Hutchinson, Colquhoun – Taylor, Anderson,
  McKee – Champ, Bell, Marshall, Logan, Aitken.
Labour: Roberts – Rogers, McCulloch – Ure, Lawson, Tommy Gardiner –
  Atkinson, Fullerton, Scholes, George Houison, Tiny Thombs.

1920 – Winners – HAMILTON WESTINGHOUSE
July 3, 1920, in Toronto
Toronto Willys Overland  2 (Bailey, F. Dierden)
Hamilton Westinghouse  3 (Thombs 2, Pilkington)
HT:           Att:           Ref: O. Hill (St. Catharines)
Willys: Harry Stansfield – Drummond, Fred Dierden – Art Dierden, Woods,
  Bailey – Hunt, Herring, Lawrie, MacFarlane, Taylor.
Westinghouse: Coombs – McEwan, Craig – Ure, Burns, Tommy Gardiner
  – Garside, Newton, Billy Gilvear, Pilkington, Tiny Thombs.

1921 – Winners – TORONTO SCOTTISH
July 2, 1921, at Broadview Field in Toronto
Toronto Scottish  4 (Fidler, McDonald, Anderson 2)
Hamilton Independent Labour Party  1 (Borthwick)
HT:           Att:           Ref: Percy May (Ottawa)
Scottish: Steve Smith – Geordie Campbell, Houison – Harry A’Court, Alex
  McCall, Johnson – Harry Anderson, Bobby  Bruce, McDonald, Ernie
  Fidler, Teddy Young.
Labour: Joe Scanlon – Burtenshaw, McCulloch – Sincliar, Bingham,
  Cooper – Pogson, Fullerton, Scholes, Borthwick, Bell.